A review from someone who spent three weeks bouncing on a yoga ball at 3am, convinced their baby was broken—until a pediatrician mentioned “the 5 S’s” and everything changed
You’ve tried everything. Feeding. Burping. Diaper changes. Rocking. Singing. Driving around the block at midnight. Standing in the bathroom with the fan running. Crying yourself because nothing works and you haven’t slept in days.
Your baby screams. And screams. And screams.
You start googling things like “why won’t my baby stop crying” and “is my baby okay” and “how long can a person survive without sleep” and “is it normal to regret having children.”
You’re not a bad parent. You’re not doing anything wrong. You just haven’t learned the secret language of newborns yet.
Dr. Harvey Karp’s The Happiest Baby on the Block claims to have cracked the code. His “5 S’s” method promises to calm crying babies—even colicky ones—within minutes. Not through magic, but through understanding what babies actually need in those first few months of life.
Bold claims. But does it actually work? Let’s find out.
🎧 Want the Audiobook for FREE?
Before we dive in, here’s a little-known trick to get this audiobook at no cost:
- Click the link above to view The Happiest Baby on the Block on Amazon
- Look for the “+ Audiobook” option when selecting your format
- Sign up for a free 30-day Audible trial
- Receive the full audiobook as part of your trial
- Keep the audiobook forever—even if you cancel the trial before it renews!
Listen while bouncing your baby at 2am, cancel within 30 days, pay nothing, and keep the audiobook permanently. Sleep-deprived parents can absorb audio better than text anyway. 🎧📚
What Is This Book? 🤔
The Happiest Baby on the Block introduces the “fourth trimester” concept and the calming techniques that flow from it.
The core theory:
Human babies are born too early. Unlike other mammals who can walk within hours, human infants are essentially fetuses for the first three months of life. They need womb-like conditions to feel calm and secure.
The 5 S’s method:
- Swaddling – Tight wrapping that mimics the womb
- Side/Stomach – Holding baby on side or stomach (for calming, not sleeping)
- Shushing – Loud white noise that mimics womb sounds
- Swinging – Rhythmic, jiggly movement
- Sucking – Pacifier or finger for non-nutritive sucking
The book argues these five techniques, done correctly and in combination, trigger a “calming reflex” that can soothe even the fussiest babies.
It’s focused specifically on the newborn period (0-3 months), addressing the desperate question every new parent asks: How do I make the crying stop? 📖
The Good Stuff ✅
The “Fourth Trimester” Concept Is Genuinely Helpful
Understanding why babies cry changes everything:
The insight:
Human babies are born “premature” compared to other mammals because our big brains and bipedal hips create a delivery problem. If babies stayed in the womb until they were as developed as a newborn horse, they couldn’t fit through the birth canal.
The implication:
For the first three months, babies aren’t really ready for the outside world. They’re expecting the womb—tight, warm, loud, constantly moving. Instead, they get wide-open spaces, silence, stillness. No wonder they cry.
The reframe:
Your baby isn’t broken. They’re not “colicky” in some mysterious way. They’re homesick for an environment we can partially recreate.
Why this helps:
Instead of feeling helpless and confused, parents have a framework. The crying makes sense. The solutions follow logically. Understanding reduces panic.
This concept alone is worth the book price. 🎯
The 5 S’s Actually Work (For Many Babies)
The techniques have helped millions of parents:
Swaddling:
Tight wrapping restricts the startle reflex that wakes babies and recreates the snug feeling of the womb. Many babies who fight swaddling initially relax once fully wrapped.
Side/Stomach position:
Holding babies on their side or stomach (while awake and supervised) often calms them faster than back-lying. This is for soothing only—always put babies on their backs to sleep.
Shushing:
The womb is loud—about as loud as a vacuum cleaner. Gentle “shh shh shh” or white noise machines recreate this. The shushing needs to be louder than the crying to work.
Swinging:
Not gentle rocking—Karp describes a small, quick, jiggly movement that mimics the constant motion babies experienced in utero. Support the head and move in small, fast motions.
Sucking:
Non-nutritive sucking activates the calming reflex. Pacifiers, fingers, or nursing for comfort all work.
The key:
All five together, done correctly. One S might not work alone. The combination triggers what Karp calls the “calming reflex”—an off-switch for crying.
When it works, it feels like magic. ✨
It Gives Exhausted Parents Something to DO
The helplessness is the hardest part:
Without this book:
Baby cries. You try random things. Nothing works. You feel incompetent, desperate, like a failure.
With this book:
Baby cries. You run through the 5 S’s systematically. You have a checklist, a method, a protocol. Even if it doesn’t work perfectly, you’re doing something with purpose.
The psychological benefit:
Having a plan reduces parental anxiety. Feeling competent helps with bonding. Knowing what to try next prevents despair.
The practical benefit:
Even if the 5 S’s don’t stop all crying, they give exhausted parents a framework instead of random flailing at 3am.
Something to try beats nothing to try. 💪
The Technique Instructions Are Specific
Karp doesn’t just say “swaddle your baby.” He explains exactly how:
The specificity:
Swaddling: Arms down, blanket tight, no loose fabric. Karp provides the “DUDU” wrap method (Down-Up-Down-Up) with step-by-step instructions.
Shushing: Louder than you think. Match the intensity of the cry. Right next to the ear. Sustained, not just a few “shh’s.”
Swinging: Small movements, about 1-2 inches. Fast—like jiggling Jello. Always support the head. Not big swaying motions.
Why this matters:
Many parents try the 5 S’s and say they don’t work—but they’re doing them too gently, too briefly, or incorrectly. Karp’s detailed instructions help parents get the technique right.
The video helps:
There’s also a DVD/video version that demonstrates the techniques. For visual learners, seeing the jiggly swing motion is worth a thousand words.
Specificity enables success. 🌟
It Addresses Colic Directly
For parents of colicky babies, this book is a lifeline:
The traditional view:
Colic is mysterious, untreatable, and you just have to wait it out. Three months of hell with no solution.
Karp’s view:
Most “colic” is simply a baby’s need for fourth-trimester conditions not being met. The crying isn’t random or meaningless—it’s communication.
The hope:
You’re not helpless. Your baby isn’t broken. There are things you can try that might actually help.
The caveat:
Karp’s claims about colic are stronger than the evidence fully supports. But for desperate parents, having something to try—and understanding why their baby might be crying—is genuinely helpful.
Even partial relief from colic is life-changing. 🛡️
It’s a Quick Read (Essential for New Parents)
The book respects your limited time:
The format:
Clear chapters, practical focus, not overly long. You can absorb the core concepts in a few hours.
The reality:
New parents don’t have time for 400-page tomes. They need information they can apply immediately.
The approach:
Karp explains the theory enough to be convincing, then moves quickly to practical application. The balance is appropriate for exhausted readers.
The alternative:
The video/DVD version presents the same information even faster for those who can’t focus on text.
Accessible when accessibility matters most. 📝
The Not-So-Good Stuff 😬
The Claims Can Be Overblown
Karp’s confidence exceeds the evidence:
The promise:
“Calm any crying baby in minutes!” “The cure for colic!”
The reality:
The 5 S’s work well for many babies. They don’t work for all babies. Some crying has causes the 5 S’s can’t address—hunger, illness, discomfort, overtiredness.
The problem:
Parents who try the techniques “correctly” and still have crying babies may feel like failures. The marketing sets expectations that can’t always be met.
The truth:
These are helpful techniques that work for many families. They’re not magic that works for everyone every time.
Helpful? Yes. Miracle cure? No. 😬
Swaddling Concerns Have Evolved
Since the book’s publication, swaddling guidance has changed:
The concerns:
Hip dysplasia: Tight swaddling of legs can contribute to hip problems. Modern guidance recommends loose swaddling around hips—”hip-healthy swaddling.”
Overheating: Swaddled babies can overheat, increasing SIDS risk. Monitoring temperature is important.
Rolling risk: Once babies start rolling, swaddling becomes dangerous. Many babies roll earlier than expected.
SIDS research: Some studies have raised concerns about swaddling and SIDS risk, particularly after 2 months or when babies are placed on their stomachs.
The update needed:
The current safe sleep guidelines should be followed. Swaddling can be helpful but needs to be done according to current safety recommendations, which have evolved since the book was written.
Check current AAP guidelines alongside this book. 🚩
The “Side/Stomach” Position Requires Clarification
This S causes confusion:
What Karp means:
Hold baby on their side or stomach while awake, in your arms, for soothing. This is a calming position, not a sleep position.
What some parents hear:
Put baby on stomach to sleep.
The danger:
Back sleeping is essential for safe sleep. Stomach sleeping significantly increases SIDS risk. The “side/stomach” S is for soothing while supervised only.
The responsibility:
Karp does clarify this, but the potential for misunderstanding is real. The emphasis on safe sleep could be stronger.
Safe sleep is non-negotiable. Always back to sleep. 🩺
It’s Primarily Focused on 0-3 Months
The book’s scope is narrow:
What it covers:
Newborns. The fourth trimester. The first three months.
What it doesn’t cover:
- Sleep training
- Older baby soothing
- Developmental stages
- Feeding challenges
- Anything beyond the newborn phase
The expectation management:
This is a specialized book for a specialized time. It’s not a comprehensive infant parenting guide.
The implication:
You’ll need other resources as your baby grows. The 5 S’s become less relevant after 3-4 months when babies outgrow the calming reflex.
Useful but limited window. 📉
The Writing Can Be Repetitive
The book’s style may frustrate:
The pattern:
Karp makes a point. Then makes it again. Then illustrates with an anecdote. Then repeats the point. The core content could be condensed significantly.
The experience:
Sleep-deprived parents might find the repetition helpful (things sink in better when repeated). Others find it padding.
The alternative:
The video version is more concise. Some parents prefer to watch the DVD and skip the book.
The reality:
You can skim significant portions and still get the full value. The core techniques are simple—the book adds context, stories, and reinforcement.
Could be half the length. 😬
The “Calming Reflex” Science Is Debated
The theoretical underpinning has critics:
Karp’s claim:
There’s a neurological “calming reflex” that the 5 S’s trigger—like an off-switch for crying.
The debate:
Some researchers question whether this specific reflex exists as Karp describes it. The techniques may work for other reasons—comfort, sensory input, parental confidence—rather than a specific neurological mechanism.
The practical implication:
Does it matter why it works if it works? For most parents, no. But the scientific framing is more confident than the evidence fully supports.
The bottom line:
The techniques can be helpful regardless of whether the “calming reflex” theory is precisely correct.
The practice may be better than the theory. 🧠
It Can Create Dependency Concerns
Some parents worry about long-term effects:
The concern:
If babies need swaddling, white noise, and motion to sleep, are we creating dependencies that will be hard to break?
The reality:
Most babies naturally outgrow these needs. The fourth trimester ends around 3-4 months, and babies become more adaptable.
The transition:
There will likely be a transition period when weaning from swaddles and white noise. This isn’t necessarily harder than any other baby transition.
The perspective:
A well-rested family in the newborn period is more important than avoiding theoretical future difficulties. Solve today’s problem today.
Short-term survival matters more than theoretical concerns. 💭
Neurodivergent Babies May Need Different Approaches
The familiar gap:
What’s not addressed:
- Sensory processing differences
- Babies who are over-sensitive to stimulation
- Babies who don’t respond to typical soothing
- When the 5 S’s make things worse
The assumption:
All babies have the same calming reflex that responds to the same techniques.
The reality:
Some babies are genuinely different. Babies who later are identified as autistic or with sensory processing differences may not respond typically.
The guidance needed:
When to recognize that something else is going on and seek professional support.
Not all babies fit the mold. 😬
Who Is This For? 🎯
Perfect if you:
- Have a newborn (0-3 months)
- Are desperate to soothe a crying baby
- Want specific, actionable techniques
- Need a framework to reduce helplessness
- Have a “colicky” baby and need hope
- Can read current safe sleep guidelines alongside the book
- Want something you can apply immediately
Not ideal if you:
- Have an older baby (4+ months)
- Want comprehensive infant parenting guidance
- Need evidence-based resources with current research
- Are looking for sleep training information
- Expect guaranteed results
- Have a baby with unusual needs or sensitivities
Alternatives Worth Considering 🔄
Precious Little Sleep by Alexis Dubief: Covers newborn soothing AND sleep training as baby grows. More comprehensive, very practical. Great next book after Happiest Baby. 🏆
The Wonder Weeks by Frans Plooij: Explains developmental leaps that cause fussiness. Helps you understand why baby is suddenly crying more. Good companion resource.
Cribsheet by Emily Oster: Data-driven look at infant care decisions. More analytical approach if you want evidence over anecdote.
The Happiest Baby Guide to Great Sleep by Harvey Karp: Karp’s follow-up focusing specifically on sleep through toddlerhood. Natural continuation.
Healthy Sleep Habits, Happy Child by Marc Weissbluth: Comprehensive sleep guidance from newborn through childhood. More technical but thorough. 📚
The Final Verdict 🏅
The Happiest Baby on the Block has helped millions of desperate parents survive the newborn trenches. The fourth trimester concept provides a framework for understanding newborn needs. The 5 S’s offer specific, actionable techniques that genuinely work for many babies. And the simple fact of having something to try reduces the helplessness that makes early parenting so hard.
For parents drowning in newborn chaos, this book can be a lifeline.
However, the claims are sometimes overblown, the science is debated, and safety guidance has evolved since publication. It’s narrowly focused on 0-3 months, doesn’t address all babies equally, and should be paired with current safe sleep recommendations.
The useful parts:
- Fourth trimester concept: genuinely helpful framework
- 5 S’s technique: specific, actionable, often effective
- Reduces parental helplessness: something to try matters
- Quick read: respects your limited time
- Colic hope: offers possibilities for desperate parents
- Specific instructions: detailed enough to actually implement
The problematic parts:
- Overblown claims: not a guaranteed cure
- Evolving safety guidance: check current recommendations
- Narrow focus: only covers 0-3 months
- Repetitive writing: could be more concise
- Debated science: theory may be less solid than presented
- Not universal: doesn’t work for all babies
The best approach: Read this during pregnancy or the first weeks with your newborn. Learn the 5 S’s properly—watch the video if helpful. Apply the techniques with realistic expectations. Check current safe sleep guidelines for swaddling and sleep position. And recognize that if it doesn’t work perfectly for your baby, that doesn’t mean you’re doing it wrong.
The bottom line: The Happiest Baby on the Block isn’t a miracle cure, despite what the marketing suggests. But it’s a genuinely useful resource that has helped countless parents through the hardest weeks of early parenthood. The 5 S’s won’t work for every baby every time—but they work often enough to be worth knowing.
The newborn phase is survival mode. Anything that helps you survive it—that gives you techniques to try, a framework for understanding, and hope that this phase will pass—is valuable.
This book provides all three. And at 3am with a screaming baby, that’s worth everything. 👶✨
Did the 5 S’s work for your baby? What was your experience with these techniques? What else helped during the newborn trenches? Share your thoughts below!
Leave a Reply