There is a moment in every new father’s life when the hospital staff hands him a baby, points him toward the exit, and essentially says good luck. No exam. No certification. No proof of competence required. You walked in as a regular person and you are walking out responsible for keeping a seven-pound human alive indefinitely. The car seat alone has more instructions than you received for the actual child.

Gary Greenberg and Jeannie Hayden understood this moment. They understood the terror behind the smile. They understood that most new fathers are not looking for a philosophical treatise on the meaning of fatherhood or a comprehensive medical reference covering every possible infant ailment. They are looking for someone to tell them, in plain language, how to do this. How to hold the baby. How to change the diaper. How to survive on no sleep. How to not destroy their marriage. How to fake confidence when they have none.

“Be Prepared: A Practical Handbook for New Dads” is that someone. Published in 2004, this slim, illustrated, deliberately funny book has become one of the most gifted and most beloved new dad books in existence. It is the book that appears at baby showers wrapped in blue paper. It is the book that sits on the back of the toilet in new parent households across America. It is the book that fathers actually read, cover to cover, sometimes in a single sitting, because it is short enough, funny enough, and useful enough to hold the attention of a man who has not finished a book since college.

But beneath the humor, is there substance? Can a book that teaches you how to baby-proof a hotel room and fashion a diaper from a restaurant napkin actually prepare you for fatherhood? Or is it just a novelty item dressed as a parenting resource? In this review we will examine what “Be Prepared” gets right, what it gets wrong, and who it is really for.

Get the dad handbook you actually want to read: Search for “Be Prepared Gary Greenberg” on Amazon

The Format: A Field Manual, Not a Textbook

The first thing you notice about “Be Prepared” is that it looks nothing like a traditional parenting book. It is designed to resemble a vintage Boy Scout handbook or a military field manual, complete with retro-style illustrations, diagrams, and step-by-step visual instructions. The cover features a father confidently holding a baby in one arm while the other arm appears ready for anything. The aesthetic communicates immediately: this is not your partner’s parenting book. This is yours.

Inside, the book is organized not by the baby’s age or developmental stage but by topic. There are sections on feeding, sleeping, crying, diapering, bathing, traveling, baby-proofing, and managing the relationship with your partner. Each section is broken into short, punchy entries that read more like how-to articles than book chapters. Most entries are one to three pages long. Many include illustrated diagrams showing exactly how to perform the task being described.

This format is a deliberate and brilliant design choice. New fathers are not going to sit down with a 400-page book and read it sequentially. They are going to grab it off the shelf at two in the morning because the baby will not stop crying and they need an answer now. The short, indexed, heavily illustrated format means you can find what you need in seconds and apply it immediately.

The book also includes what Greenberg calls “survival tips,” which are scattered throughout like field notes from a combat veteran. These range from the genuinely practical (“Keep a spare outfit for yourself in the diaper bag, not just the baby”) to the darkly funny (“If you feel yourself getting frustrated, put the baby down in a safe place and walk away. The baby will still be crying when you come back, but at least you’ll have had a moment to remember that you love them”).

The Humor: Why It Works

The humor in “Be Prepared” is not incidental. It is structural. It is the load-bearing wall of the entire book, and understanding why it works is essential to understanding why the book has endured.

New fatherhood is terrifying. The responsibility is crushing. The sleep deprivation is hallucinatory. The learning curve is vertical. And the emotional experience is a chaotic mix of love, fear, inadequacy, and occasional regret that no one warned you about because admitting those feelings violates the cultural code of fatherhood.

Humor is the pressure valve. When Greenberg describes the meconium diaper as looking like something that should be reported to the EPA, or when he provides step-by-step instructions for changing a diaper in the back of a car as though it were a tactical operation, he is not trivializing the experience. He is giving fathers permission to laugh at the absurdity of it. And that laughter is a form of coping that many men desperately need and rarely receive.

The humor also serves as a Trojan horse for genuine information. A father who would never read a chapter titled “Infant Feeding Strategies” will happily read a section titled “How to Prepare a Bottle Without Fully Waking Up.” The content is the same. The packaging makes it accessible.

Greenberg understands his audience. He understands that many men process information better when it is delivered with levity. He understands that a man who feels incompetent is more likely to engage with material that acknowledges his incompetence with a wink rather than material that lectures him about the importance of paternal involvement. The humor says “We know this is ridiculous. We know you feel unprepared. Here’s what to do anyway.”

What the Book Actually Teaches

Beneath the jokes, the practical content is surprisingly comprehensive for such a short book.

Diapering

The diapering section is one of the best in any new parent resource. Greenberg provides clear, illustrated instructions for changing both wet and soiled diapers, including the specific technique for cleaning a baby girl versus a baby boy. He addresses the projectile urination that catches every new parent of a boy off guard. He describes how to change a diaper in unconventional locations, including on your lap, in a car, and on an airplane. He covers diaper rash identification and treatment.

Most usefully, he normalizes the experience. New fathers are often genuinely disgusted by diapers and ashamed of their disgust. Greenberg acknowledges the disgust, makes a joke about it, and then teaches you how to do it anyway. The message is clear: being grossed out does not make you a bad father. Refusing to do it anyway would.

Feeding

The feeding section covers both breastfeeding support and bottle-feeding technique. Greenberg is refreshingly practical about breastfeeding. He does not lecture fathers about its importance. He explains what the father’s role is during breastfeeding: bringing water, managing the nursing pillow, handling burping, and generally being useful rather than decorative.

For bottle-feeding, he provides clear instructions on preparation, temperature testing, feeding position, burping technique, and cleaning. He addresses the middle-of-the-night bottle preparation with the strategic precision of a man who has done it hundreds of times in the dark.

Sleep

The sleep section is honest and darkly funny. Greenberg does not pretend that the newborn sleep phase is anything other than brutal. He provides strategies for surviving on minimal sleep, including napping when the baby naps, sharing nighttime duties with your partner, and accepting that your cognitive function will be impaired for months.

He also provides practical guidance on safe sleep positioning, swaddling technique, and creating a sleep environment. His advice on putting a baby to sleep, involving motion, white noise, and patience, is solid and aligns with mainstream recommendations.

Survive the newborn phase with humor intact: Search for “Be Prepared Gary Greenberg” on Amazon

Crying

The crying section is where the book shines brightest as a practical resource. Greenberg provides a systematic checklist for diagnosing the cause of crying: hunger, diaper, temperature, discomfort, overstimulation, understimulation, illness. He walks through each possibility with enough detail to be useful without enough detail to be overwhelming.

He then provides a toolkit of soothing strategies, including rocking, bouncing, walking, shushing, white noise, car rides, and the desperate last resort of putting the baby in the car seat on top of the running dryer. He notes that different babies respond to different strategies and encourages fathers to experiment rather than assuming that the first technique that fails means all techniques will fail.

Most importantly, he addresses the rage that can build in a parent who has been listening to inconsolable crying for hours. He does this without judgment and with an explicit safety message: if you feel yourself losing control, put the baby down and walk away. This is not failure. This is safety. Call someone. Take a breath. Come back.

Baby-Proofing

The baby-proofing section approaches the topic with the systematic thoroughness of a safety inspector and the paranoia of a first-time father who has just realized that his home is essentially a death trap. Greenberg covers electrical outlets, stairs, cabinets, drawers, cords, sharp corners, heavy objects, small objects, water hazards, and the existential threat posed by the family dog who has not yet been introduced to the new household member.

The illustrations are particularly useful here, showing exactly where to install gates, how to secure furniture to walls, and which common household items are choking hazards. For visual learners, these diagrams communicate more effectively than paragraphs of text.

The Relationship Section: Brief but Honest

Greenberg devotes a section to the impact of a new baby on the parents’ relationship, and while it is shorter than the topic deserves, it is remarkably honest.

He acknowledges that the arrival of a baby detonates the existing relationship dynamic. Sleep deprivation makes everyone irritable. The division of labor becomes a source of resentment. Intimacy evaporates. Communication deteriorates into logistics. The couple who used to talk about movies and dreams now talks exclusively about feeding schedules and diaper contents.

He provides practical advice for maintaining the relationship: schedule time alone together even if it is just twenty minutes after the baby sleeps, express appreciation for your partner explicitly and often, do not keep score on who got up more times last night, and accept that the relationship will feel different for a while and that different does not mean broken.

He also addresses the return to sexual intimacy with the kind of direct, unsentimental honesty that men appreciate. He explains the physical recovery timeline for the mother, the hormonal changes that affect desire, the exhaustion that makes both partners prefer sleep to sex, and the need for patience and communication. He does not promise a timeline. He promises that it gets better.

What the Book Does Not Do

Understanding the limitations of “Be Prepared” is essential to using it correctly.

The book does not cover infant health in any meaningful depth. If your baby has a fever, a rash, or a concerning symptom, this is not the book to consult. You need a medical reference or a phone call to your pediatrician. Greenberg wisely does not attempt to practice medicine. He stays in his lane, which is practical daily care, and directs readers to medical professionals for anything beyond that.

The book does not address infant development. There are no milestone charts, no cognitive development explanations, no guidance on what your baby should be doing at four months versus eight months. Fathers who want to understand what is happening inside their baby’s brain will need a different resource.

The book does not engage with parenting philosophy. There is no discussion of attachment parenting versus scheduled parenting, no debate about co-sleeping versus crib sleeping, no position on breastfeeding versus formula. Greenberg is agnostic on ideology. He just wants you to know how to do the thing, whatever the thing is. This neutrality is both a strength and a limitation. It avoids the judgment that pervades many parenting books but also avoids the deeper questions about why you might choose one approach over another.

The book does not deeply address paternal emotions. Unlike “The Expectant Father” by Armin Brott, which spends extensive time on the father’s psychological experience, “Be Prepared” keeps the emotional content light. The humor serves as emotional support, but fathers who are genuinely struggling with anxiety, depression, or the identity crisis of new parenthood will need a more substantive resource.

The book’s scope is limited to roughly the first year. As the baby transitions into toddlerhood, the book’s usefulness fades. Greenberg does not attempt to cover discipline, language development, or the behavioral challenges that emerge after the first birthday.

Equip yourself for the first year of fatherhood: Search for “Be Prepared Gary Greenberg” on Amazon

The Honest Critique

The humor, while generally effective, occasionally overshadows the content. There are moments when a father in genuine distress might find the jokey tone grating rather than reassuring. When you are running on two hours of sleep and your baby has been screaming for three hours, a quip about tactical diaper changes may not land the way it would on a calm afternoon.

The book can reinforce a gendered division of parenting labor, albeit unintentionally. By framing fatherhood as a separate, distinctly male experience requiring its own specially packaged guide, the book can inadvertently suggest that fathers are a different species of parent who need simpler instructions and more jokes. Some fathers may find this framing refreshing and relatable. Others may find it slightly patronizing.

The diversity of family structures is not well represented. The book assumes a heterosexual two-parent household. Single fathers, gay fathers, adoptive fathers, and fathers in non-traditional family configurations will find the practical content useful but the relationship and partner sections irrelevant or exclusionary.

The illustrations, while charming and retro, depict a very narrow range of family types. Updated editions would benefit from more diverse visual representation.

Some of the specific practical advice has been overtaken by changes in safety recommendations. Parents should cross-reference any safety-related guidance with current AAP guidelines, as recommendations on sleep positioning, car seat usage, and other safety topics evolve regularly.

Comparison to Other Dad Books

Compared to “The Expectant Father” by Armin Brott, which covers pregnancy in depth and takes the father’s emotional experience seriously, “Be Prepared” is more practical and less psychological. Brott prepares you for the emotional journey. Greenberg prepares you for the Tuesday afternoon when the baby has a blowout in the grocery store. Ideally, read both.

Compared to “Dude, You’re Gonna Be a Dad!” by John Pfeiffer, which is also humor-driven, “Be Prepared” is more practically useful. Pfeiffer is funnier. Greenberg is more helpful. Both are short enough to read in a single sitting.

Compared to “The New Father” by Armin Brott, which covers the first year in comprehensive detail with developmental information and emotional guidance, “Be Prepared” is lighter and faster but less thorough. Brott is the textbook. Greenberg is the cheat sheet.

Who Should Read This Book

First-time fathers who are overwhelmed by the prospect of caring for a newborn and want a quick, practical, confidence-building resource should start here. This is the on-ramp to fatherhood for men who do not read parenting books.

Partners who want to give the expectant father something he will actually read should buy this book. It is the most reliably read dad book on the market for a reason.

Fathers who learn by doing rather than by reading will appreciate the illustrated, step-by-step format. The diagrams communicate more than paragraphs ever could.

Second-time fathers who want a refresher on the practical basics will find this book useful for brushing up on skills that may have gotten rusty.

However, fathers looking for emotional depth, developmental guidance, or parenting philosophy should supplement this book with more substantive resources. “Be Prepared” is the starter kit, not the complete toolkit.

The Final Verdict

“Be Prepared” is not the most comprehensive fatherhood book. It is not the most emotionally intelligent. It is not the most scientifically rigorous. It is not the most culturally inclusive.

But it might be the most effective.

Because the best parenting book is the one you actually read. And “Be Prepared” is the one that fathers actually read. It meets men where they are, which is often terrified, clueless, and unwilling to admit either of those things. It hands them practical skills wrapped in humor and says you can do this, and it is going to be ridiculous, and that is completely fine.

Gary Greenberg did not write the definitive guide to fatherhood. He wrote the book that gets fathers through the door. And once you are through the door, once you have changed your first diaper and survived your first sleepless night and learned that you can in fact keep a small human alive, you discover something that no book can fully prepare you for.

You discover that you are a father. Not a perfect one. Not a prepared one. But a real one. And that is more than enough.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.