B# Be Prepared by Gary Greenberg: A Deep Dive Review
**A review from someone who didn’t want to read a parenting book but needed to know how to change a diaper on the hood of a car—and found exactly that information, with diagrams**
You’re about to become a father. Everyone tells you to read parenting books. So you pick one up, and it’s 400 pages about bonding and emotional attunement and the profound spiritual journey of parenthood.
You put it down. You’ll figure it out.
But here’s the thing: you actually don’t know how to change a diaper. You’ve never swaddled anything. You have no idea how to hold a newborn without feeling like you’re going to break it. And no one seems to be addressing the practical question of how to function on two hours of sleep without killing someone.
Where’s the parenting book that treats fatherhood like a survival situation? That gives you actual skills instead of philosophy? That acknowledges you might need to know how to change a diaper in a restaurant bathroom with no changing table, not just in a beautifully organized nursery?
Gary Greenberg and Jeannie Hayden’s [*Be Prepared: A Practical Handbook for New Dads*](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Be+Prepared+A+Practical+Handbook+for+New+Dads+Gary+Greenberg&tag=tinytotsonline-20) is that book. It’s a field guide to the first year of fatherhood—written like a survival manual, complete with diagrams, step-by-step instructions, and the assumption that you know absolutely nothing and need to learn fast.
It’s the parenting book for dads who don’t want to read parenting books. But is it actually useful? Let’s find out.
—
## 🎧 Want the Audiobook for FREE?
Before we dive in, here’s a little-known trick to get this audiobook at no cost:
1. **Click the link above** to view [*Be Prepared: A Practical Handbook for New Dads*](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Be+Prepared+A+Practical+Handbook+for+New+Dads+Gary+Greenberg&tag=tinytotsonline-20) on Amazon
2. **Look for the “+ Audiobook” option** when selecting your format
3. **Sign up for a free 30-day Audible trial**
4. **Receive the full audiobook** as part of your trial
5. **Keep the audiobook forever**—even if you cancel the trial before it renews!
Listen while assembling the crib you should have assembled weeks ago, cancel within 30 days, pay nothing, and keep the audiobook permanently. Though honestly, this book’s diagrams mean the physical copy might be more useful. 🎧📚
—
## What Is This Book? 🤔
[*Be Prepared*](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Be+Prepared+A+Practical+Handbook+for+New+Dads+Gary+Greenberg&tag=tinytotsonline-20) is a practical survival guide for new fathers, covering roughly the first year of your baby’s life. It’s designed to look and feel like a Boy Scout handbook or wilderness survival guide—because that’s essentially what new fatherhood is: survival in unfamiliar territory.
**The format:**
– Organized by topic, not chronology
– Heavy on illustrations and diagrams
– Step-by-step instructions for practical skills
– Humor throughout without sacrificing usefulness
– Quick-reference sections for emergencies
– Designed to be grabbed off the shelf when you need specific help
**The coverage:**
– Diapering (including challenging locations)
– Feeding (bottles, burping, solid foods)
– Sleep (getting baby to sleep, surviving sleep deprivation)
– Crying (soothing techniques, colic survival)
– Safety and first aid
– Gear and equipment
– Traveling with baby
– Returning to normal life (work, social life, sex)
– Childproofing
– Developmental milestones
**The philosophy:**
You don’t need to become a different person to be a good dad. You need skills, information, and a sense of humor. This book provides all three without lecturing you about what fatherhood should mean.
It’s the tactical manual for Operation: Baby. 📖
—
## The Good Stuff ✅
### It Treats You Like a Capable Adult Who Needs Information
No condescension, no hand-holding:
**The assumption:**
You’re smart, capable, and willing to learn. You just don’t know this particular skillset yet.
**The approach:**
Here’s what you need to know. Here’s how to do it. Here’s a diagram. Here’s what to do when it goes wrong.
**The tone:**
Like a more experienced friend showing you the ropes. Not a lecture, not a therapy session—just practical guidance.
**The respect:**
You can figure this out. You’re not an incompetent sitcom dad who needs to be managed. You’re a person learning a new skill.
**The relief:**
For dads who felt talked down to by other parenting resources, this book treats you as an equal.
Information delivery, not ideology delivery. 🎯
### The Diagrams Are Actually Useful
Visual learning for visual skills:
**What’s illustrated:**
– How to hold a baby (multiple positions)
– How to swaddle step-by-step
– Diaper changing technique
– How to burp a baby
– Car seat installation
– Baby-wearing carrier setup
– Childproofing problem spots
– Bath time procedures
**Why this matters:**
Some things are hard to explain in words. “Support the head” makes more sense when you can see exactly where your hand goes.
**The style:**
Clear, simple line drawings. Not trying to be cute—trying to be useful.
**The reference value:**
When you’re standing over a screaming baby at 3am trying to remember how to swaddle, you can flip to the diagram instead of reading paragraphs.
**The accessibility:**
Dads who wouldn’t read a text-heavy parenting book will look at pictures. Greenberg knows this.
A picture is worth a thousand words of parenting advice. ✨
### It Covers Scenarios Other Books Ignore
Real-world situations, not just ideal conditions:
**Examples of coverage:**
*Changing a diaper without a changing table:*
On your lap, on a car hood, on the floor of a bathroom stall. Actual techniques for less-than-ideal locations.
*Surviving sleep deprivation:*
Not just “sleep when baby sleeps” (useless advice), but actual strategies for functioning on minimal sleep. Coffee guidance. Microsleep warnings. When to tag out.
*Taking baby to a restaurant:*
Timing, positioning, escape plans, realistic expectations.
*Flying with an infant:*
What to bring, what to expect, how to handle pressure changes and crying on planes.
*Going back to work:*
The emotional and practical challenges. How to stay connected. Managing the transition.
*Sex after baby:*
When, how, realistic expectations, what changes.
**The practicality:**
Other books tell you about bonding. This book tells you how to change a blowout diaper in an airplane bathroom.
Both are useful. Only one is rare.
Real life isn’t always a well-stocked nursery. 💪
### The Humor Makes It Actually Readable
Funny without being frivolous:
**The approach:**
Parenting is absurd. Babies are weird. Sleep deprivation makes everything surreal. The book acknowledges this.
**The effect:**
You actually want to read it. It’s not a chore. The humor keeps you engaged when the material might otherwise be dry.
**The examples:**
– Comparing diaper contents to various substances
– Honest descriptions of what sleep deprivation feels like
– Acknowledgment of how ridiculous some baby gear is
– Self-deprecating new dad moments
**The balance:**
Funny enough to be entertaining, serious enough to be useful. The humor never undermines the practical value.
**The stress relief:**
Laughing about the chaos helps. The book gives you permission to find the absurdity funny.
Humor as coping mechanism—and engagement tool. 🌟
### The First Aid Section Is Essential
What every parent needs to know:
**What’s covered:**
– Infant CPR basics
– Choking response
– When to call the doctor
– Common injuries and responses
– Fever guidelines
– Signs of serious illness
– Emergency numbers and information
**The format:**
Quick reference style. Not comprehensive medical training, but enough to respond appropriately while getting professional help.
**The emphasis:**
Know what’s an emergency and what isn’t. Know what to do in the first few minutes.
**The reality:**
You probably won’t take a full infant CPR class (though you should). This section gives you something.
**The caveat:**
This doesn’t replace actual first aid training. But it’s better than nothing, and it might be what you have access to at 2am.
Every parent should know this stuff. 🛡️
### It’s Designed for How Dads Actually Use Books
Reference, not reading:
**The design:**
– Table of contents you can actually navigate
– Index for finding specific topics
– Sections you can read independently
– Quick-reference formats for emergencies
– Not dependent on reading sequentially
**The reality:**
You won’t read this cover to cover before baby arrives. You’ll grab it when you need to know something specific.
**The accessibility:**
Find what you need fast. Get the information. Put the book down. Handle the situation.
**The acknowledgment:**
New parents don’t have time for leisurely reading. The book doesn’t pretend otherwise.
**The result:**
A book that actually gets used, not one that sits on the shelf looking impressive.
Designed for real usage patterns. 📝
### It Acknowledges the Partner Relationship
Not just baby care—relationship survival:
**What’s addressed:**
– How baby affects your relationship
– Supporting your partner postpartum
– Division of labor negotiations
– Keeping connection alive
– The sex conversation (honestly)
– Managing conflict during the sleep-deprived phase
**The honesty:**
This is hard on relationships. You’ll fight more. You’ll have less time for each other. That’s normal.
**The practical suggestions:**
Not just “communicate more” but actual strategies for maintaining partnership while drowning in baby care.
**The perspective:**
Your partner is going through something too. Here’s how to not make it worse—and maybe even help.
**The balance:**
Baby-focused but relationship-aware.
Partnership matters for parenting. 🧠
—
## The Not-So-Good Stuff 😬
### It’s Light on Emotional Content
Practical doesn’t mean complete:
**What’s missing:**
– Deep exploration of the emotional transformation of fatherhood
– Processing complicated feelings about becoming a parent
– Bonding struggles and what to do about them
– Postpartum depression in fathers
– Grief about life changes
– Fear and anxiety management
**The trade-off:**
The book’s strength (practical, no-nonsense) is also its limitation. Emotional complexity isn’t really addressed.
**The gap:**
For dads struggling with the psychological aspects of new fatherhood, this book won’t provide much support.
**The complement needed:**
Pair with something that addresses the emotional side—[*The Expectant Father*](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=The+Expectant+Father+The+Ultimate+Guide+for+Dads-to-Be+Armin+Brott&tag=tinytotsonline-20) or [*The New Father: A Dad’s Guide to the First Year*](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=The+New+Father+A+Dads+Guide+to+the+First+Year+Armin+Brott&tag=tinytotsonline-20) provides more emotional depth.
**The reality:**
Some dads want practical without emotional. Others need both.
Skills without feelings. 😬
### The Humor Can Feel Dated
Written in a specific era:
**The style:**
Early 2000s dad humor. Some jokes that felt edgy then feel obvious or tired now.
**The references:**
Some cultural touchpoints have aged. Not dramatically, but noticeably.
**The tone:**
Occasionally veers into “dads are bumbling but well-meaning” territory that some modern fathers find limiting.
**The gender dynamics:**
Some assumptions about division of labor reflect when the book was written, not necessarily modern family structures.
**The impact:**
Mildly annoying, not deal-breaking. The practical content remains solid.
Comedy ages faster than information. 🚩
### It Assumes a Specific Family Structure
Limitations in scope:
**The assumptions:**
– Heterosexual couple
– Mother as primary caregiver
– Father as secondary/supporting parent
– Traditional-ish division of labor
**Who’s not centered:**
– Single fathers
– Same-sex parents
– Primary caregiver dads
– Non-traditional family structures
**The language:**
“Your wife/partner” throughout, with traditional dynamics assumed.
**The adaptation:**
The practical skills translate regardless of family structure. The framing may not.
**The limitation:**
Not everyone’s fatherhood looks like this book assumes.
Traditional assumptions throughout. 📉
### Medical Information May Be Outdated
Guidelines change:
**The concern:**
Recommendations about sleep positioning, feeding, car seat installation, and other safety topics evolve.
**The reality:**
First published in 2004, updated since, but may not reflect the most current guidelines.
**The recommendation:**
Use this book for general skills and approaches. Verify specific safety recommendations with current sources (AAP guidelines, car seat manufacturers, pediatrician).
**The risk:**
Following outdated safety advice could be harmful.
**The approach:**
Cross-reference anything safety-related with current guidelines.
Always verify medical and safety information. 🩺
### It Ends at Year One
Coverage limitations:
**What’s covered:**
Roughly the first year of life.
**What’s not covered:**
– Toddlerhood
– Discipline approaches
– Language development
– Preschool years
– Long-term parenting philosophy
**The gap:**
If you loved this book’s approach, there’s no sequel covering ages 1-5 in the same style.
**The alternatives:**
You’ll need different resources for ongoing parenting guidance beyond infancy.
**The reality:**
One book can’t cover everything. But the drop-off at year one is abrupt.
First year only. 📉
### Some Skills Are Better Learned Hands-On
Books have limits:
**The truth:**
You can read about swaddling. You can look at diagrams. But actually learning to swaddle requires a baby (or a doll) and practice.
**The limitation:**
The book describes skills you need to physically practice. Reading isn’t the same as doing.
**The examples:**
– Diaper changing (coordination and speed come from practice)
– Baby-wearing (fit and adjustment are hands-on)
– Car seat installation (every car and seat is different)
– Infant CPR (absolutely requires hands-on training)
**The recommendation:**
Use the book as preparation and reference, but actually practice the physical skills.
**The complement:**
Take a baby care class if available. Practice on dolls. Ask experienced parents to demonstrate.
Reading isn’t doing. 🧠
### The “Survival” Framing Can Minimize
Language matters:
**The metaphor:**
Parenting as survival. Baby as adversary to be managed. Fatherhood as something to get through.
**The concern:**
This framing, while relatable and funny, can minimize the positive aspects of new parenthood. It can reinforce the idea that dads are just trying to survive while moms do the real parenting.
**The balance:**
The humor helps. But “surviving” your baby isn’t really the goal—connecting with them is.
**The limitation:**
If you approach fatherhood as primarily something to survive, you might miss the joy.
**The perspective:**
Useful framing for the hard parts. Not the whole story.
Survival isn’t the whole experience. 😬
### It Doesn’t Address Feeding Beyond Basics
Limited nutrition guidance:
**What’s covered:**
Basic bottle feeding, burping, starting solids.
**What’s missing:**
– Supporting breastfeeding partner
– Pumping and bottle prep in depth
– Baby-led weaning vs. purees debate
– Allergies and introduction of allergens
– Picky eating
– Nutrition beyond formula/breast milk basics
**The gap:**
Feeding is one of the most time-consuming aspects of infant care. The coverage feels thin.
**The supplement needed:**
Additional resources for feeding decisions and challenges.
More feeding depth would help. 📉
—
## Who Is This For? 🎯
**Perfect if you:**
– Don’t want to read traditional parenting books
– Learn best from practical, visual information
– Appreciate humor in parenting guidance
– Want skills, not philosophy
– Need a quick reference for specific situations
– Are in a relatively traditional family structure
– Want to feel competent, not transformed
**Not ideal if you:**
– Need emotional support for the fatherhood transition
– Want in-depth exploration of child development
– Are in a non-traditional family structure needing specific guidance
– Need current medical and safety information
– Want coverage beyond the first year
– Prefer research-cited, evidence-based approaches
– Are looking for your primary, comprehensive parenting resource
—
## Alternatives Worth Considering 🔄
[**The Expectant Father: The Ultimate Guide for Dads-to-Be**](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=The+Expectant+Father+The+Ultimate+Guide+for+Dads-to-Be+Armin+Brott&tag=tinytotsonline-20) by Armin A. Brott: Covers pregnancy from dad’s perspective. More emotional depth, similar practical focus. Great companion for before baby arrives. 🏆
[**The New Father: A Dad’s Guide to the First Year**](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=The+New+Father+A+Dads+Guide+to+the+First+Year+Armin+Brott&tag=tinytotsonline-20) by Armin A. Brott: Month-by-month first year guide. More comprehensive, more emotional content, less humorous. Good complement or alternative.
[**Dude, You’re Gonna Be a Dad!**](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Dude+Youre+Gonna+Be+a+Dad+John+Pfeiffer&tag=tinytotsonline-20) by John Pfeiffer: Similar humor-forward approach for expectant dads. Covers pregnancy rather than first year.
[**Heading Home with Your Newborn**](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Heading+Home+with+Your+Newborn+Laura+Jana&tag=tinytotsonline-20) by Laura Jana: From the American Academy of Pediatrics. More medically focused, current guidelines, less humor but more authority.
[**The Happiest Baby on the Block**](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=The+Happiest+Baby+on+the+Block+Harvey+Karp&tag=tinytotsonline-20) by Harvey Karp: Focused specifically on soothing newborns. If calming a crying baby is your main concern, this goes deeper than Be Prepared.
[**Cribsheet**](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Cribsheet+Emily+Oster&tag=tinytotsonline-20) by Emily Oster: Data-driven approach to baby decisions. For dads who want evidence and research, not just techniques. 📚
—
## The Final Verdict 🏅
[*Be Prepared: A Practical Handbook for New Dads*](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Be+Prepared+A+Practical+Handbook+for+New+Dads+Gary+Greenberg&tag=tinytotsonline-20) succeeds at exactly what it sets out to do: give new dads practical skills and information without drowning them in philosophy, emotion, or condescension. The field-guide format works. The diagrams are genuinely useful. The humor makes it readable. And the coverage of real-world scenarios (not just ideal conditions) sets it apart from prettier but less practical resources.
For dads who want to feel competent rather than transformed, who need to know how to do things rather than how to feel about them, this book delivers.
**However**, the emotional dimensions of fatherhood are largely ignored. The humor and assumptions feel somewhat dated. The family structure assumptions are traditional. And medical/safety information should be verified against current guidelines.
**The useful parts:**
– Practical skills focus: actually learn to do things
– Useful diagrams: visual learning for physical skills
– Real-world scenarios: not just ideal conditions
– Humor that engages: actually want to read it
– Reference design: find what you need fast
– First aid basics: essential information
– Respects your intelligence: no condescension
**The problematic parts:**
– Light on emotional content: skills without feelings
– Dated humor and assumptions: written in different era
– Traditional family structure assumed: limited scope
– Medical information may be outdated: verify safety guidance
– Ends at year one: no coverage beyond infancy
– Survival framing: can minimize the positive
– Feeding coverage thin: needs supplementation
**The best approach:** Use this as your practical quick-reference guide, especially in the early months when you need to know how to do specific things. Supplement with resources that address emotional content, current safety guidelines, and coverage beyond the first year. Don’t use this as your only parenting book—use it as your tactical manual alongside more comprehensive resources.
**The bottom line:** [*Be Prepared*](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Be+Prepared+A+Practical+Handbook+for+New+Dads+Gary+Greenberg&tag=tinytotsonline-20) is the parenting book for dads who don’t read parenting books. It meets you where you are—probably skeptical of soft parenting advice, probably wanting concrete skills, probably appreciating humor over earnestness.
And that’s valuable. Because the truth is, you DO need to know how to change a diaper. You DO need to know how to soothe a crying baby. You DO need practical skills that no one teaches you.
This book teaches them. Quickly, clearly, with diagrams and jokes.
Is that all there is to fatherhood? No. Not even close. The emotional transformation, the relationship with your child, the person you become—that’s the bigger story.
But you can’t get to the bigger story if you don’t survive the first year. And this book helps you survive it—competently, maybe even with some laughs along the way.
Sometimes that’s exactly what you need. 👶🛠️✨
—
**Did Be Prepared help you feel more competent as a new dad? What practical skills were you most glad to learn? What did you wish the book had covered? Share your experience below!**e Prepared by Gary Greenberg: A Deep Dive Review
A review from someone who didn’t want to read a parenting book but needed to know how to change a diaper on the hood of a car—and found exactly that information, with diagrams
You’re about to become a father. Everyone tells you to read parenting books. So you pick one up, and it’s 400 pages about bonding and emotional attunement and the profound spiritual journey of parenthood.
You put it down. You’ll figure it out.
But here’s the thing: you actually don’t know how to change a diaper. You’ve never swaddled anything. You have no idea how to hold a newborn without feeling like you’re going to break it. And no one seems to be addressing the practical question of how to function on two hours of sleep without killing someone.
Where’s the parenting book that treats fatherhood like a survival situation? That gives you actual skills instead of philosophy? That acknowledges you might need to know how to change a diaper in a restaurant bathroom with no changing table, not just in a beautifully organized nursery?
Gary Greenberg and Jeannie Hayden’s Be Prepared: A Practical Handbook for New Dads is that book. It’s a field guide to the first year of fatherhood—written like a survival manual, complete with diagrams, step-by-step instructions, and the assumption that you know absolutely nothing and need to learn fast.
It’s the parenting book for dads who don’t want to read parenting books. But is it actually useful? Let’s find out.
🎧 Want the Audiobook for FREE?
Before we dive in, here’s a little-known trick to get this audiobook at no cost:
- Click the link above to view Be Prepared: A Practical Handbook for New Dads on Amazon
- Look for the “+ Audiobook” option when selecting your format
- Sign up for a free 30-day Audible trial
- Receive the full audiobook as part of your trial
- Keep the audiobook forever—even if you cancel the trial before it renews!
Listen while assembling the crib you should have assembled weeks ago, cancel within 30 days, pay nothing, and keep the audiobook permanently. Though honestly, this book’s diagrams mean the physical copy might be more useful. 🎧📚
What Is This Book? 🤔
Be Prepared is a practical survival guide for new fathers, covering roughly the first year of your baby’s life. It’s designed to look and feel like a Boy Scout handbook or wilderness survival guide—because that’s essentially what new fatherhood is: survival in unfamiliar territory.
The format:
- Organized by topic, not chronology
- Heavy on illustrations and diagrams
- Step-by-step instructions for practical skills
- Humor throughout without sacrificing usefulness
- Quick-reference sections for emergencies
- Designed to be grabbed off the shelf when you need specific help
The coverage:
- Diapering (including challenging locations)
- Feeding (bottles, burping, solid foods)
- Sleep (getting baby to sleep, surviving sleep deprivation)
- Crying (soothing techniques, colic survival)
- Safety and first aid
- Gear and equipment
- Traveling with baby
- Returning to normal life (work, social life, sex)
- Childproofing
- Developmental milestones
The philosophy:
You don’t need to become a different person to be a good dad. You need skills, information, and a sense of humor. This book provides all three without lecturing you about what fatherhood should mean.
It’s the tactical manual for Operation: Baby. 📖
The Good Stuff ✅
It Treats You Like a Capable Adult Who Needs Information
No condescension, no hand-holding:
The assumption:
You’re smart, capable, and willing to learn. You just don’t know this particular skillset yet.
The approach:
Here’s what you need to know. Here’s how to do it. Here’s a diagram. Here’s what to do when it goes wrong.
The tone:
Like a more experienced friend showing you the ropes. Not a lecture, not a therapy session—just practical guidance.
The respect:
You can figure this out. You’re not an incompetent sitcom dad who needs to be managed. You’re a person learning a new skill.
The relief:
For dads who felt talked down to by other parenting resources, this book treats you as an equal.
Information delivery, not ideology delivery. 🎯
The Diagrams Are Actually Useful
Visual learning for visual skills:
What’s illustrated:
- How to hold a baby (multiple positions)
- How to swaddle step-by-step
- Diaper changing technique
- How to burp a baby
- Car seat installation
- Baby-wearing carrier setup
- Childproofing problem spots
- Bath time procedures
Why this matters:
Some things are hard to explain in words. “Support the head” makes more sense when you can see exactly where your hand goes.
The style:
Clear, simple line drawings. Not trying to be cute—trying to be useful.
The reference value:
When you’re standing over a screaming baby at 3am trying to remember how to swaddle, you can flip to the diagram instead of reading paragraphs.
The accessibility:
Dads who wouldn’t read a text-heavy parenting book will look at pictures. Greenberg knows this.
A picture is worth a thousand words of parenting advice. ✨
It Covers Scenarios Other Books Ignore
Real-world situations, not just ideal conditions:
Examples of coverage:
Changing a diaper without a changing table:
On your lap, on a car hood, on the floor of a bathroom stall. Actual techniques for less-than-ideal locations.
Surviving sleep deprivation:
Not just “sleep when baby sleeps” (useless advice), but actual strategies for functioning on minimal sleep. Coffee guidance. Microsleep warnings. When to tag out.
Taking baby to a restaurant:
Timing, positioning, escape plans, realistic expectations.
Flying with an infant:
What to bring, what to expect, how to handle pressure changes and crying on planes.
Going back to work:
The emotional and practical challenges. How to stay connected. Managing the transition.
Sex after baby:
When, how, realistic expectations, what changes.
The practicality:
Other books tell you about bonding. This book tells you how to change a blowout diaper in an airplane bathroom.
Both are useful. Only one is rare.
Real life isn’t always a well-stocked nursery. 💪
The Humor Makes It Actually Readable
Funny without being frivolous:
The approach:
Parenting is absurd. Babies are weird. Sleep deprivation makes everything surreal. The book acknowledges this.
The effect:
You actually want to read it. It’s not a chore. The humor keeps you engaged when the material might otherwise be dry.
The examples:
- Comparing diaper contents to various substances
- Honest descriptions of what sleep deprivation feels like
- Acknowledgment of how ridiculous some baby gear is
- Self-deprecating new dad moments
The balance:
Funny enough to be entertaining, serious enough to be useful. The humor never undermines the practical value.
The stress relief:
Laughing about the chaos helps. The book gives you permission to find the absurdity funny.
Humor as coping mechanism—and engagement tool. 🌟
The First Aid Section Is Essential
What every parent needs to know:
What’s covered:
- Infant CPR basics
- Choking response
- When to call the doctor
- Common injuries and responses
- Fever guidelines
- Signs of serious illness
- Emergency numbers and information
The format:
Quick reference style. Not comprehensive medical training, but enough to respond appropriately while getting professional help.
The emphasis:
Know what’s an emergency and what isn’t. Know what to do in the first few minutes.
The reality:
You probably won’t take a full infant CPR class (though you should). This section gives you something.
The caveat:
This doesn’t replace actual first aid training. But it’s better than nothing, and it might be what you have access to at 2am.
Every parent should know this stuff. 🛡️
It’s Designed for How Dads Actually Use Books
Reference, not reading:
The design:
- Table of contents you can actually navigate
- Index for finding specific topics
- Sections you can read independently
- Quick-reference formats for emergencies
- Not dependent on reading sequentially
The reality:
You won’t read this cover to cover before baby arrives. You’ll grab it when you need to know something specific.
The accessibility:
Find what you need fast. Get the information. Put the book down. Handle the situation.
The acknowledgment:
New parents don’t have time for leisurely reading. The book doesn’t pretend otherwise.
The result:
A book that actually gets used, not one that sits on the shelf looking impressive.
Designed for real usage patterns. 📝
It Acknowledges the Partner Relationship
Not just baby care—relationship survival:
What’s addressed:
- How baby affects your relationship
- Supporting your partner postpartum
- Division of labor negotiations
- Keeping connection alive
- The sex conversation (honestly)
- Managing conflict during the sleep-deprived phase
The honesty:
This is hard on relationships. You’ll fight more. You’ll have less time for each other. That’s normal.
The practical suggestions:
Not just “communicate more” but actual strategies for maintaining partnership while drowning in baby care.
The perspective:
Your partner is going through something too. Here’s how to not make it worse—and maybe even help.
The balance:
Baby-focused but relationship-aware.
Partnership matters for parenting. 🧠
The Not-So-Good Stuff 😬
It’s Light on Emotional Content
Practical doesn’t mean complete:
What’s missing:
- Deep exploration of the emotional transformation of fatherhood
- Processing complicated feelings about becoming a parent
- Bonding struggles and what to do about them
- Postpartum depression in fathers
- Grief about life changes
- Fear and anxiety management
The trade-off:
The book’s strength (practical, no-nonsense) is also its limitation. Emotional complexity isn’t really addressed.
The gap:
For dads struggling with the psychological aspects of new fatherhood, this book won’t provide much support.
The complement needed:
Pair with something that addresses the emotional side—The Expectant Father or The New Father: A Dad’s Guide to the First Year provides more emotional depth.
The reality:
Some dads want practical without emotional. Others need both.
Skills without feelings. 😬
The Humor Can Feel Dated
Written in a specific era:
The style:
Early 2000s dad humor. Some jokes that felt edgy then feel obvious or tired now.
The references:
Some cultural touchpoints have aged. Not dramatically, but noticeably.
The tone:
Occasionally veers into “dads are bumbling but well-meaning” territory that some modern fathers find limiting.
The gender dynamics:
Some assumptions about division of labor reflect when the book was written, not necessarily modern family structures.
The impact:
Mildly annoying, not deal-breaking. The practical content remains solid.
Comedy ages faster than information. 🚩
It Assumes a Specific Family Structure
Limitations in scope:
The assumptions:
- Heterosexual couple
- Mother as primary caregiver
- Father as secondary/supporting parent
- Traditional-ish division of labor
Who’s not centered:
- Single fathers
- Same-sex parents
- Primary caregiver dads
- Non-traditional family structures
The language:
“Your wife/partner” throughout, with traditional dynamics assumed.
The adaptation:
The practical skills translate regardless of family structure. The framing may not.
The limitation:
Not everyone’s fatherhood looks like this book assumes.
Traditional assumptions throughout. 📉
Medical Information May Be Outdated
Guidelines change:
The concern:
Recommendations about sleep positioning, feeding, car seat installation, and other safety topics evolve.
The reality:
First published in 2004, updated since, but may not reflect the most current guidelines.
The recommendation:
Use this book for general skills and approaches. Verify specific safety recommendations with current sources (AAP guidelines, car seat manufacturers, pediatrician).
The risk:
Following outdated safety advice could be harmful.
The approach:
Cross-reference anything safety-related with current guidelines.
Always verify medical and safety information. 🩺
It Ends at Year One
Coverage limitations:
What’s covered:
Roughly the first year of life.
What’s not covered:
- Toddlerhood
- Discipline approaches
- Language development
- Preschool years
- Long-term parenting philosophy
The gap:
If you loved this book’s approach, there’s no sequel covering ages 1-5 in the same style.
The alternatives:
You’ll need different resources for ongoing parenting guidance beyond infancy.
The reality:
One book can’t cover everything. But the drop-off at year one is abrupt.
First year only. 📉
Some Skills Are Better Learned Hands-On
Books have limits:
The truth:
You can read about swaddling. You can look at diagrams. But actually learning to swaddle requires a baby (or a doll) and practice.
The limitation:
The book describes skills you need to physically practice. Reading isn’t the same as doing.
The examples:
- Diaper changing (coordination and speed come from practice)
- Baby-wearing (fit and adjustment are hands-on)
- Car seat installation (every car and seat is different)
- Infant CPR (absolutely requires hands-on training)
The recommendation:
Use the book as preparation and reference, but actually practice the physical skills.
The complement:
Take a baby care class if available. Practice on dolls. Ask experienced parents to demonstrate.
Reading isn’t doing. 🧠
The “Survival” Framing Can Minimize
Language matters:
The metaphor:
Parenting as survival. Baby as adversary to be managed. Fatherhood as something to get through.
The concern:
This framing, while relatable and funny, can minimize the positive aspects of new parenthood. It can reinforce the idea that dads are just trying to survive while moms do the real parenting.
The balance:
The humor helps. But “surviving” your baby isn’t really the goal—connecting with them is.
The limitation:
If you approach fatherhood as primarily something to survive, you might miss the joy.
The perspective:
Useful framing for the hard parts. Not the whole story.
Survival isn’t the whole experience. 😬
It Doesn’t Address Feeding Beyond Basics
Limited nutrition guidance:
What’s covered:
Basic bottle feeding, burping, starting solids.
What’s missing:
- Supporting breastfeeding partner
- Pumping and bottle prep in depth
- Baby-led weaning vs. purees debate
- Allergies and introduction of allergens
- Picky eating
- Nutrition beyond formula/breast milk basics
The gap:
Feeding is one of the most time-consuming aspects of infant care. The coverage feels thin.
The supplement needed:
Additional resources for feeding decisions and challenges.
More feeding depth would help. 📉
Who Is This For? 🎯
Perfect if you:
- Don’t want to read traditional parenting books
- Learn best from practical, visual information
- Appreciate humor in parenting guidance
- Want skills, not philosophy
- Need a quick reference for specific situations
- Are in a relatively traditional family structure
- Want to feel competent, not transformed
Not ideal if you:
- Need emotional support for the fatherhood transition
- Want in-depth exploration of child development
- Are in a non-traditional family structure needing specific guidance
- Need current medical and safety information
- Want coverage beyond the first year
- Prefer research-cited, evidence-based approaches
- Are looking for your primary, comprehensive parenting resource
Alternatives Worth Considering 🔄
The Expectant Father: The Ultimate Guide for Dads-to-Be by Armin A. Brott: Covers pregnancy from dad’s perspective. More emotional depth, similar practical focus. Great companion for before baby arrives. 🏆
The New Father: A Dad’s Guide to the First Year by Armin A. Brott: Month-by-month first year guide. More comprehensive, more emotional content, less humorous. Good complement or alternative.
Dude, You’re Gonna Be a Dad! by John Pfeiffer: Similar humor-forward approach for expectant dads. Covers pregnancy rather than first year.
Heading Home with Your Newborn by Laura Jana: From the American Academy of Pediatrics. More medically focused, current guidelines, less humor but more authority.
The Happiest Baby on the Block by Harvey Karp: Focused specifically on soothing newborns. If calming a crying baby is your main concern, this goes deeper than Be Prepared.
Cribsheet by Emily Oster: Data-driven approach to baby decisions. For dads who want evidence and research, not just techniques. 📚
The Final Verdict 🏅
Be Prepared: A Practical Handbook for New Dads succeeds at exactly what it sets out to do: give new dads practical skills and information without drowning them in philosophy, emotion, or condescension. The field-guide format works. The diagrams are genuinely useful. The humor makes it readable. And the coverage of real-world scenarios (not just ideal conditions) sets it apart from prettier but less practical resources.
For dads who want to feel competent rather than transformed, who need to know how to do things rather than how to feel about them, this book delivers.
However, the emotional dimensions of fatherhood are largely ignored. The humor and assumptions feel somewhat dated. The family structure assumptions are traditional. And medical/safety information should be verified against current guidelines.
The useful parts:
- Practical skills focus: actually learn to do things
- Useful diagrams: visual learning for physical skills
- Real-world scenarios: not just ideal conditions
- Humor that engages: actually want to read it
- Reference design: find what you need fast
- First aid basics: essential information
- Respects your intelligence: no condescension
The problematic parts:
- Light on emotional content: skills without feelings
- Dated humor and assumptions: written in different era
- Traditional family structure assumed: limited scope
- Medical information may be outdated: verify safety guidance
- Ends at year one: no coverage beyond infancy
- Survival framing: can minimize the positive
- Feeding coverage thin: needs supplementation
The best approach: Use this as your practical quick-reference guide, especially in the early months when you need to know how to do specific things. Supplement with resources that address emotional content, current safety guidelines, and coverage beyond the first year. Don’t use this as your only parenting book—use it as your tactical manual alongside more comprehensive resources.
The bottom line: Be Prepared is the parenting book for dads who don’t read parenting books. It meets you where you are—probably skeptical of soft parenting advice, probably wanting concrete skills, probably appreciating humor over earnestness.
And that’s valuable. Because the truth is, you DO need to know how to change a diaper. You DO need to know how to soothe a crying baby. You DO need practical skills that no one teaches you.
This book teaches them. Quickly, clearly, with diagrams and jokes.
Is that all there is to fatherhood? No. Not even close. The emotional transformation, the relationship with your child, the person you become—that’s the bigger story.
But you can’t get to the bigger story if you don’t survive the first year. And this book helps you survive it—competently, maybe even with some laughs along the way.
Sometimes that’s exactly what you need. 👶🛠️✨
Did Be Prepared help you feel more competent as a new dad? What practical skills were you most glad to learn? What did you wish the book had covered? Share your experience below!
Leave a Reply